### Top 10 Arxiv Papers Today in History And Philosophy Of Physics

##### #1. Newton's graphical method as a canonical transformation
###### Siu A. Chin
This work shows that, Newton's Proposition 1 in the {\it Principia}, is an {\it exact} graphical representation of a canonical transformation, a first-order symplectic integrator generated at a finite time-step by the Hamiltonian. A fundamental characteristic of this canonical transformation is to update the position and velocity vectors {\it sequentially}, thereby automatically conserving the phase-volume and the areal velocity due to a central force. As a consequence, the continuous force is naturally replaced by a series of impulses. The convergence of Newton's Proposition 1 in the limit of $\Delta t\rightarrow 0$ can be proved easily and the resulting error term for the linear and the inverse square force can explain why Hooke was able to the obtain an elliptical orbit for the former but not the latter.
more | pdf | html
###### Tweets
qraal: [1810.05264] Newton's graphical method as a canonical transformation https://t.co/aCfGfulAUf
PhysicsPaper: Newton's graphical method as a canonical transformation. https://t.co/dCOXar1PpF
Vagelford: Newton's graphical method as a canonical transformation https://t.co/pNysoZ8PWW
None.
None.
###### Other stats
Sample Sizes : None.
Authors: 1
Total Words: 3828
Unqiue Words: 1283

##### #2. Taking Mermin's Relational Interpretation of QM Beyond Cabello's and Seevinck's No-Go Theorems
###### Christian de Ronde, Raimundo Fernández Mouján, César Massri
In this paper we address a deeply interesting debate that took place at the end of the last millennia between David Mermin, Adan Cabello and Michiel Seevinck, regarding the meaning of relationalism within quantum theory. In a series of papers, Mermin proposed an interpretation in which quantum correlations were considered as elements of physical reality. Unfortunately, the very young relational proposal by Mermin was too soon tackled by specially suited no-go theorems designed by Cabello and Seevinck. In this work we attempt to reconsider Mermin's program from the viewpoint of the Logos Categorical Approach to QM. Following Mermin's original proposal, we will provide a redefinition of quantum relation which not only can be understood as a preexistent element of physical reality but is also capable to escape Cabello's and Seevinck's no-go-theorems. In order to show explicitly that our notion of ontological quantum relation is safe from no-go theorems we will derive a non-contextuality theorem. We end the paper with a discussion...
more | pdf | html
None.
None.
###### Other stats
Sample Sizes : None.
Authors: 3
Total Words: 10446
Unqiue Words: 2708

##### #3. How the Saha Ionization Equation Was Discovered
###### Arnab Rai Choudhuri
Although the Saha ionization equation is a standard topic in advanced statistical physics and most professional physicists would have some knowledge of it, the exact nature of Meghnad Saha's contributions in this subject is not widely known. Based on an analysis of Saha's original papers and other relevant papers by contemporary scientists, as well as other source materials such as letters exchanged between scientists, I discuss how Saha used the theory of thermal ionization to solve some of the most important astrophysics problems of that era.
more | pdf | html
None.
None.
###### Other stats
Sample Sizes : None.
Authors: 1
Total Words: 11982
Unqiue Words: 3119

##### #4. On Geometric Objects, the Non-Existence of a Gravitational Stress-Energy Tensor, and the Uniqueness of the Einstein Field Equation
###### Erik Curiel
The question of the existence of gravitational stress-energy in general relativity has exercised investigators in the field since the inception of the theory. Folklore has it that no adequate definition of a localized gravitational stress-energetic quantity can be given. Most arguments to that effect invoke one version or another of the Principle of Equivalence. I argue that not only are such arguments of necessity vague and hand-waving but, worse, are beside the point and do not address the heart of the issue. Based on a novel analysis of what it may mean for one tensor to depend in the proper way on another, which, \emph{en passant}, provides a precise characterization of the idea of a `geometric object', I prove that, under certain natural conditions, there can be no tensor whose interpretation could be that it represents gravitational stress-energy in general relativity. It follows that gravitational energy, such as it is in general relativity, is necessarily non-local. Along the way, I prove a result of some interest in own...
more | pdf | html
None.
None.
None.
###### Other stats
Sample Sizes : None.
Authors: 1
Total Words: 15784
Unqiue Words: 3398

##### #5. Twin Suns in Australian Aboriginal Traditions
###### Duane W. Hamacher, Rubina R. Visuvanathan
The oral traditions of Aboriginal cultures across Australia contain references to the presence of multiple Suns in the sky at the same time. Explanations of this have been largely regarded as symbolic or mythological, rather than observations of natural phenomena. In this paper, we examine oral traditions describing multiple Suns and analyse interpretations that could explain them. Our analysis of the oral traditions concludes that descriptions of multiple Suns fall into two main categories: one describing the changes in the path of the Sun throughout the year, and the other describing observations of parhelia, an atmospheric phenomenon known as 'Sun dogs' that creates an optical illusion of multiple Suns in the sky at once. This analysis shows how Aboriginal people pay close attention to natural phenomena, assign them social meaning, and incorporate them into oral tradition.
more | pdf | html
###### Tweets
DuaneHamacher: Congrats to Rubina Visuvanathan in Malaysia for her first publication, which we wrote together entitled "Twin Suns in Australian Aboriginal Traditions" in the next issue of the @AstroHeritage. https://t.co/mXBPWullcG https://t.co/e1dyvdLlRl
PhysicsPaper: Twin Suns in Australian Aboriginal Traditions. https://t.co/sa7Ljl2sEu
None.
None.
###### Other stats
Sample Sizes : None.
Authors: 2
Total Words: 5456
Unqiue Words: 2109

##### #6. Hubble Law or Hubble-Lemaître Law? The IAU Resolution
###### Helge Kragh
The Hubble law, widely considered the first observational basis for the expansion of the universe, may in the future be known as the Hubble-Lema\^itre law. This is what the General Assembly of the International Astronomical Union recommended at its recent meeting in Vienna. However, the resolution in favour of a renamed law is problematic in so far as concerns its arguments based on the history of cosmology in the relevant period from about 1927 to the early 1930s. A critical examination of the resolution reveals flaws of a non-trivial nature. The purpose of this note is to highlight these problems and to provide a better historically informed background for the voting among the union's members, which in a few months' time will result in either a confirmation or a rejection of the decision made by the General Assembly.
more | pdf | html
None.
###### Tweets
PhysicsPaper: Hubble Law or Hubble-Lema\^itre Law? The IAU Resolution. https://t.co/JwkXiIfuYu
Mike_Banks: Should the Hubble Law be renamed the Hubble-Lemaître Law? https://t.co/ihy4FI0349 #arXiv
aCimarron: "Hubble Law or Hubble-Lema\^itre Law? The IAU Resolution. (arXiv:1809.02557v1 [physics.hist-ph])" https://t.co/Y0vr4EcZYl
None.
None.
###### Other stats
Sample Sizes : None.
Authors: 1
Total Words: 2841
Unqiue Words: 1107

##### #7. Karl Popper's Forgotten Role in the Quantum Debate at the Edge between Philosophy and Physics in 1950s and 1960s
###### Flavio Del Santo
It is not very well known that the philosopher Karl Popper has been one of the foremost critics of the orthodox interpretation of quantum physics for about six decades. This paper reconstructs in detail most of Popper's activities on foundations of quantum mechanics (FQM) in the period of 1950s and 1960s, when his involvement in the community of quantum physicists became extensive and quite influential. Thanks to unpublished documents and correspondence, it is now possible to shed new light on Popper's central - though neglected - role in this "thought collective" of physicists concerned with FQM, and on the intellectual relationships that Popper established in this context with some of the protagonists of the debate over quantum physics (such as David Bohm, Alfed Land\'e and Henry Margenau, among many others). Foundations of quantum mechanics represented in those years also the initial ground for the embittering controversy between Popper and perhaps his most notable former student, Paul Feyerabend. I present here novel elements...
more | pdf | html
None.
###### Tweets
aCimarron: Karl Popper's Forgotten Role in the Quantum Debate at the Edge between Philosophy and Physics in 1950s and 1960s. (arXiv:1811.00902v1 [physics.hist-ph]) https://t.co/pj1iiil2t4
QuantumPapers: Karl Popper's Forgotten Role in the Quantum Debate at the Edge between Philosophy and Physics in 1950s and 1960s. https://t.co/JoBHOXc7Az
hiropon_matsu: "Karl Popper's Forgotten Role in the Quantum Debate at the Edge between Philosophy and Physics in 1950s and 1960s." https://t.co/UE4MHxcn7n
None.
None.
###### Other stats
Sample Sizes : None.
Authors: 1
Total Words: 10917
Unqiue Words: 3204

##### #8. Finetuned Cancellations and Improbable Theories
###### James D. Wells
It is argued that the $x-y$ cancellation model (XYCM) is a good proxy for discussions of finetuned cancellations in physical theories. XYCM is then analyzed from a statistical perspective, where it is argued that a finetuned point in the parameter space is not abnormal, with any such point being just as probable as any other point. However, landing inside a standardly defined finetuned region (i.e., the full parameter space of finetuned points) has a much lower probability than landing outside the region, and that probability is invariant under assumed ranges of parameters. This proposition requires asserting also that the finetuned target region is a priori established. Therefore, it is surmised that highly finetuned theories are generally expected to be highly improbable. An actionable implication of this moderate naturalness position is that the search for a non-finetuned explanation to supplant an apparently finetuned theory is likely to be a valid pursuit, but not guaranteed to be. A statistical characterization of this...
more | pdf | html
###### Tweets
jwellsX: Giving it my best shot to articulate a connection between finetuning and a theory's improbability. https://t.co/lRs6b3yO0J
TheoryPapers: Finetuned Cancellations and Improbable Theories. https://t.co/C3KIpUvP5q
qraal: Finetuned Cancellations and Improbable Theories https://t.co/sib56MC0uV
mikraemer: RT @jwellsX: Giving it my best shot to articulate a connection between finetuning and a theory's improbability. https://t.co/lRs6b3yO0J
thiagrr: RT @jwellsX: Giving it my best shot to articulate a connection between finetuning and a theory's improbability. https://t.co/lRs6b3yO0J
None.
None.
###### Other stats
Sample Sizes : None.
Authors: 1
Total Words: 6441
Unqiue Words: 1764

##### #9. Probabilism for Stochastic Theories
###### Jeremy Steeger
I defend an analog of probabilism that characterizes rationally coherent estimates for chances. Specifically, I demonstrate the following accuracy-dominance result for stochastic theories in the C*-algebraic framework: supposing an assignment of chance values is possible if and only if it is given by a pure state on a given algebra, your estimates for chances avoid accuracy-dominance if and only if they are given by a state on that algebra. When your estimates avoid accuracy-dominance (roughly: when you cannot guarantee that other estimates would be more accurate), I say that they are sufficiently coherent. In formal epistemology and quantum foundations, the notion of rational coherence that gets more attention requires that you never allow for a sure loss (or 'Dutch book') in a given sort of betting game; I call this notion full coherence. I characterize when these two notions of rational coherence align, and I show that there is a quantum state giving estimates that are sufficiently coherent, but not fully coherent.
more | pdf | html
None.
###### Tweets
QuantumPapers: Probabilism for Stochastic Theories. https://t.co/APGQwggqce
None.
None.
###### Other stats
Sample Sizes : None.
Authors: 1
Total Words: 13336
Unqiue Words: 2738

##### #10. Phases of physics in J.D. Forbes' Dissertation Sixth for the Encyclopaedia Britannica (1856)
###### Isobel Falconer
This paper takes James David Forbes' Encyclopaedia Britannica entry, Dissertation Sixth, as a lens to examine physics as a cognitive, practical, and social, enterprise. Forbes wrote this survey of eighteenth- and nineteenth-century mathematical and physical sciences, in 1852-6, when British "physics" was at a pivotal point in its history, situated between a discipline identified by its mathematical methods - originating in France - and one identified by its university laboratory institutions. Contemporary encyclopaedias provided a nexus for publishers, the book trade, readers, and men of science, in the formation of physics as a field. Forbes was both a witness, whose account of the progress of physics or natural philosophy can be explored at face value, and an agent, who exploited the opportunity offered by the Encyclopaedia Britannica in the mid nineteenth-century to enrol the broadly educated public, and scientific collective, illuminating the connection between the definition of physics and its forms of social practice. Forbes...
more | pdf | html
None.
###### Tweets
PhysicsPaper: Phases of physics in J.D. Forbes' Dissertation Sixth for the Encyclopaedia Britannica (1856). https://t.co/h6ZN3dmx9R
None.
None.
###### Other stats
Sample Sizes : None.
Authors: 1
Total Words: 13612
Unqiue Words: 4441

Assert is a website where the best academic papers on arXiv (computer science, math, physics), bioRxiv (biology), BITSS (reproducibility), EarthArXiv (earth science), engrXiv (engineering), LawArXiv (law), PsyArXiv (psychology), SocArXiv (social science), and SportRxiv (sport research) bubble to the top each day.

Papers are scored (in real-time) based on how verifiable they are (as determined by their Github repos) and how interesting they are (based on Twitter).

To see top papers, follow us on twitter @assertpub_ (arXiv), @assert_pub (bioRxiv), and @assertpub_dev (everything else).

To see beautiful figures extracted from papers, follow us on Instagram.

Tracking 72,893 papers.

###### Search
Sort results based on if they are interesting or reproducible.
Interesting
Reproducible
Online
###### Stats
Tracking 72,893 papers.